← Staten Island

Staten Island

Tottenville

The southernmost point of NYC. Suburban houses, yards, quiet streets. This is what $500K gets you when you accept a 75-minute commute. A very specific buyer, very specific lifestyle.

$1,500
1BR Avg Rent
$1,900
2BR Avg Rent
$495K
Avg Sale Price
3.80%
Rental Yield

Transit

Staten Island Railway
45
Transit Score
52
Walk Score
75 min to Midtown

For Buyers

Families who want a house with a yard inside city limits. Car required. Commute is the tradeoff, and for some buyers, it's worth it.

For Investors

Lower yield, lower liquidity. Owner-occupier market — not the right play for pure investors.

Interested in Tottenville?

BoroughKey specializes in this neighborhood. Get an intro call and we'll show you what's actually available — before it hits the big listing sites.

Talk to an Expert